Catchers are made from high density polythene [HDPE], which can only be repaired by plastic welding. No glue or resin will stick to it!
Edit: In the 1970's, before plastic welding was available, we used to repair Victa catchers with patches of galvanised iron; bashed to shape, and secured by pop rivets.
A Plastic Welder is basically a hot air gun with a small outlet, and a few different types of nozzles, all with provision for feeding in a filler rod.
As has been said, the filler rod has to be the same type of plastic as the item to be repaired. So polythene it is, for catchers.
Sometimes it can be quite difficult to determine the plastic type, but at least catchers are easy on that score.
There are commercial plastic welding firms about; they do a lot of business repairing plastic car bodywork, and motorcycle fairings.
Last edited by Gadge; 31/05/15 06:26 AM. Reason: add info