We may have had this disagreement before Bob: I think if you do the job to a workshop standard, there are advantages:
- the repair will be reliable
- future repairs will be made easier
- resale value of the item will be higher
- the repairer/owner feels proud of what has been done, not apologetic about it.
Of course it is up to the person doing, or paying for, the repairs to decide how they should be done. However it is the policy on Outdoorking to recommend only good workshop practice, for various reasons including the ones listed above. (Another reason is that good practices, like good manners, tend to be catching.)
