Hi Blumbly
The bases are very different on both sides here some better pictures that might show it better
4 Star
[Linked Image]
4 Stroke
[Linked Image]
The other side
4 Star
[Linked Image]
4 Stroke
[Linked Image]
Also the base is different when the engine fits and is listed as 2 parts in the Victa books you can see the difference as below, the engine mounts
[Linked Image]
AS you would know the 4 Star was made from 1960-61 the 4 Stroke 1961-62
I wounder there is a over lap of models or was the base shape changed while is was still a 4 Star which would explane that your two bases are the same
Ian