Hi Dave, well you have definitely got me tossed here, I have done some research for you and am stumped. Nobody I spoke to has ever heard of the name "Craftsman" be applied to a Model 45.
The plot thickens further with the pic...It has the "pram" style handlebars of the Scott Bonnar Model 45 "Lawn King" (Model Number 450546) which is different to yours (450810) which is the model number on
BOTH your machines....
The Briggs and Stratton 2.5HP on the early machine is correct for its age, but the Briggs I/C engine on the second machine would be a replacement engine in my opinion. The numbers etched into the engine rail are not original and may be an "inventory" number of the contractor or company that owned the machine previously.
Here's what we do know....Both are genuine 70's model Scott Bonnar 45's.
We know that by the 2 rail engine deck, I presume vertical screw alignment on the chain-case cover (ie. top and bottom), plastic black knobs on the grass deflector and plastic end-caps on the front roller.
Here's what I would have a think about....Rather than purchase a new handlebar assembly ($$$) for the "Craftsman", I would consider painting it hammertone blue and restoring it as a Lawn King which has that style of handle.
The second machine, paint that in the original hammertone green.
Decals are available on E-bay...just type in Scott Bonnar decals. The one you want for the second machine is the triangular one shown here, from my catcher....
![[Linked Image]](https://www.outdoorking-forum.com.au/forum/uploads/usergals/2011/04/full-1147-814-landscape.jpg)
As for which one to keep...choose to one with the less wear and tear..In other words, when inspecting under the chain-case cover, check the condition of chains and sprockets (for pointy teeth)....the cylinder reel..check for the one with the most "meat" on the blades (top of the blade to where it attaches to the reel spider)this indicates less spin-grinds....the bottom blade for wear....
As for the engine...I'm sure that grumpy (our resident Briggs guru) will jump in and explain all about the differences there.
Just remember that all parts on the 2 chassis are inter-changeable....choose the best from each to re-build the
"keeper"