G'day Sean
If the rubber starter is green then it's the rare original Auto handle the others being black , all the early
starters have cables then I think 1959 went to rope start.
The value , I have seen people pay $25 . to around the 150 dollar mark for these starters ,I paid a little
over $100. for an early auto starter that is different again to the starters you have here.
If the starter here is correct on 118,000 then your starter is not original for 114,000.
https://www.outdoorking-forum.com.au/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/47929/1.htmlCheers
Max.